Selling covered calls can be a powerful strategy, but knowing when to close a position is just as important as knowing when to open one. In this post, we’ll explore key decision factors, early close considerations, and execution strategies to help you optimize your covered call trades—read on to fine-tune your approach and boost your returns!
When Should I Close My Covered Call?
Selling covered calls is a strategy that involves specific decision-making processes. The first key aspect to consider is your profit targets. As a trader, you should have a trading plan and define these targets before trading, determining how much profit you wish to secure before closing your position. For example, aiming for a 1-2% return on your investment weekly could be a great starting point. Once you hit your target you can close and open a new one for the following week. This works pretty well if you’re selling OTM calls.

Another crucial consideration is the time value remaining on the options. Options typically lose value as expiration approaches, known as time decay. Usually on the expiry day, your option will still retain an annoyingly small (but significant) amount of extrinsic value that you need to decide whether to wait for. You could set a order to close at 80 of 90% profit, in case you reach that point long before expiry.

Responding to market trends is another factor to think about- if the underlying value has moved down significantly, maybe it’s possible to close the short position and open a new one further down the option chain – in other words, roll down.
Additionally, consider the broader market conditions. Bullish trends might offer new buying opportunities, whereas bearish trends suggest more caution. Keep an eye on market indicators like the VIX index or S&P 500 trends as these can greatly impact option prices. If the underlying is moving down, chances are there is higher volatility and better option premium.
Lastly, you can roll your option. If your option is near expiration and expected to remain stable, rolling your covered call to a future date with attractive premiums can lock in profits while extending your position.
Early Close Analysis
Deciding whether to close a covered call early involves conducting a cost/benefit evaluation. If the remaining time value is minimal or the stock price is experiencing changes, the benefits of closing early might outweigh waiting for the expiration. If you’re reaching expiration and only have a few $ left to collect in extrinsic, it’s better just to close it and open a new position for the following week.

Prevent losses – this is a pivotal factor in early closures. If the stock is dropping or experiencing increased volatility, closing a position early can prevent deeper losses. Maintaining a disciplined approach, prioritizing risk control, ensures longevity in options trading.
Consider position replacement. If the initial trade isn’t performing as expected, closing and entering a new position with a clearer prospect might be beneficial. For instance, selling a covered call with more favorable Greeks or strike prices. A delayed roll might be a good option if you’re patient and want to collect a little more premium than standard rolling. This involves closing the position and waiting for more volatility until you sell the next option.
Finally, focus on timing optimization. Sometimes, closing positions at peak liquidity periods, usually earlier in the day, ensures better fills and reduced slippage. Timing your actions optimally plays a significant role in maximizing profits and minimizing unnecessary costs. As with everything in Options – a lot comes down to patience!
Implementation Strategy
Having a solid execution method ensures that your trades are carried out smoothly. Whether you execute trades manually or automate them, consistency and accuracy in implementation protect your capital and improve outcomes. Consider using limit orders for better price controls.
Position adjustment is an ongoing process. If underlying assets fluctuate unexpectedly, tweaking your positions – like changing strike prices or expiration dates – helps maintain profitability.
Developing a thorough exit plan with specific criteria for different scenarios provides clarity. Knowing when to exit based on market signals or personal investment goals keeps the strategy disciplined and effective.
Ensure diligent record keeping. Logging each trade, including the rationale behind decisions, helps in evaluating long-term strategy effectiveness and identifying patterns or areas for improvement.
Lastly, a regular performance review is essential. Reflect on what worked, what didn’t, and why. Conduct a monthly analysis on your trading logs to glean insights, adjusting your approach for improved future results.